Semi-retrospective Sandpiper

By Keith Vinicombe

On the morning of Thursday 10 November, I discovered a greyish stint feeding with a Dunlin at the mouth of Hollow Brook, in the north-eastern corner of Chew Valley Lake, Somerset. I simply couldn’t get close to it, but it appeared to have a solidly dark crown, with no split supercilium, and a fan-shaped patch behind the eye. It also lacked any trace of a white mantle V, seemed to show a short primary projection and appeared to have a black shaft line on the feathers of the upper row of lower scapulars, expanding into a black blob towards the feather tips. All these features suggested a juvenile Semipalmated Sandpiper.

Semipalmated Sandpiper (smallest shorebird in centre of image, just right of the much-twitched Sharp-tailed Sandpiper, Chew Valley Lake, Somerset, 19 November 2011). The bird's unsplit supercilium is just visible on this photo. By Richard Andrews.

However, it was just too far away to convince me. I went back the following day and watched it for several hours, but I still couldn’t get any closer. I returned again on 15 November, this time armed with an old 60x zoom lens, which I managed to lose in the middle of a reedbed! I spent half the morning trying to find the bloody thing, which, amazingly, I did. Unfortunately, the views were no better, but I did secure 54 rather poor digiscoped images, none of which was sufficiently detailed to provide the proof that I was looking for. Reluctantly, I came to the final conclusion that I had to let it go.

On the weekend of 19 and 20 November, the stint relocated to Herriott’s Bridge at the southern end of the lake, but it was still distant (300 m). The problem now was that everybody was completely distracted by the presence of a juvenile Sharp-tailed Sandpiper that was in the same flock! I decided to try for better views once the crowds died down, but unfortunately, it left overnight on 20th.

Semipalmated Sandpiper (centre bird, Chew Valley Lake, Somerset, 19 November 2011). Note the dark crown and small fan-shaped patch behind the eye, both just visible on this digiscoped image. By Richard Andrews.

It seemed doomed to remain ‘the one that got away’, but about a week later, I had a light bulb moment. On 19 November, Richard Andrews had photographed the Sharp-tailed Sand from a ringing ride near Herriott’s Bridge. I phoned him and asked if, by any chance, he had the stint in any of his photos. To my amazement, he did, and promptly sent me 14 quite reasonable shots of it. As I opened his email, there right before my eyes, was the confirmation that I had been looking for: it was indeed a juvenile Semi-p, just beginning its moult into first-winter plumage!

Needless to say, I felt both elated and vindicated, but I also felt a little uneasy about claiming a bird retrospectively from a series of digital images. Call me old fashioned, but I prefer to identify my birds in the field. Thinking it over, I decided on a belt and braces approach: I sent the photos to Killian Mullarney, who very kindly and very promptly replied with a strong endorsement of the ID as a Semi-p.

This was the lake’s 10th BB rarity and the 16th American bird of a truly remarkable autumn. Even the ‘Good Old Days’ weren’t that good!

Wilson's Snipe

Now split from Common Snipe Gallinago gallinago, Wilson's Snipe G delicata is the lookalike Nearctic counterpart. For decades distinctions between the two have been murky, with much variation and similarity clouding the picture, but in recent years the ID criteria have become clearer and Wilson's - although still bestowed with mega rarity status - is being identified with increasing confidence and regularity in Britain. It surely remains under-recorded here, however, given that 115 have now been recorded in the Azores (for full details see the Birding Azores website).

A major photo ID guide in the January 2012 issue of Birdwatch looks at this problem, with extensive photos of both Common and Wilson's Snipe and discussion of the ID criteria for the rarer species. These videos, shared from YouTube with due credit to those who shot the footage, supplement the still images in the magazine.

 The above clip has interesting 'song' on the soundtrack.

Wilson's Snipe: accepted British records

• 1998: Lower Moors, St Mary’s, 9 October 1998-7 April 1999 (British Birds 101: 539-540).
• 2007: Lower Moors, St Mary’s, a first-winter on 3 October, with the presumed same bird from 1 October to 22 April (British Birds 103: 587); also three juveniles moulting to first-winter plumage at the same site, 21 October-26 December (British Birds 104: 582).
• 2008: Wingletang, St Agnes, 11 October (British Birds 104: 582).

In addition, it seems highly likely that the autumn 2011 bird, present at Lower Moors from September into November and documented so thoroughly with photographs, will become the seventh accepted record in due course.

References and further reading 

Bland, B. 1998. The Wilson’s Snipe on the Isles of Scilly. Birding World 11: 382-385.
Bland, B. 1999. The Wilson’s Snipe on Scilly revisited. Birding World 12: 56-61.
Reid, M. 2008. Identification of Wilson’s and Common Snipe. British Birds 101: 189-200.
Rowlands, A, Small, B J, and Bradshaw, C. 2009. From the Rarities Committee’s files: Identification of Wilson’s Snipe and assessment of the first British record. British Birds 102: 425-434.